Henry George
Milton Friedman
[A letter written in 1970 to an admirer of Henry
George]
Thank you for your letter of January 20,1979. The reason why I have
not allied myself with the "Georgist" movement is very
simple. While I share some of its views, I do not share its basic
view. The basic fundamental view of the Georgist movement as I
understand it is not only that insofar as there be property taxes they
be levied on land rather than improvements, it is not only that
property taxes at some levels may be preferable to other kinds of
taxes, but rather that property taxes should absorb essentially the
whole rent of the land, leaving the market value of the land itself
essentially zero, and that the revenue from that source should be the
sole source for governmental expenditure.
I do not share those two views. I believe that it makes far too
strict a differentiation between land and other sources of productive
services. In Ricardo's words, the original and indestructible
qualities of the land do not by any means account for all of the
current rent from land; land can be produced, its qualities can be
improved, all through investment for which there is no incentive if
the whole of the yield from improving the productivity of land or from
producing the land were to go to the government. On the other side of
the issue, there are many other resources, of which human labor is one
of the most important, which are, to put it in technical economic
jargon, in inelastic supply so that a tax on the return from such
services is unlikely to affect the amount of such services made
available for market use. The most obvious examples are such items as
the skill of Muhammad Ali or of a Frank Sinatra. These are natural
resources, too, and they are limited in supply and derive their value
from their scarcity. But here, too, I believe that incentive effects
would complicate any attempt to have anything approaching a 100
percent tax on the site value of such skills, to use George's terms.
I realize that in almost all other respects the views of the
Georgists and of my own are very much the same. I am more than glad to
join with them in common objectives, but I could not ally myself with
the Georgist movement in any sense which suggested that I agreed with
its fundamental premises.
Sincerely yours,
Milton Friedman
|