The Correspondence of Thomas Jefferson
By Subject
FRANCE / REVOLUTION
You know that the States General have met, and probably have seen the
speeches at the opening of them. The three orders sit in distinct
chambers. The great question, whether they shall vote by orders or
persons can never be surmounted amicably. It has not yet been proposed
in form; but the votes which have been taken on the outworks of that
question show that the Tiers Etat are unanimous, a good majority of
the clergy (consisting of the Cares) disposed to side with the Tiers
Etat, and in the chamber of the Noblesse, there are only fifty-four in
that sentiment, against one hundred and ninety, who are for voting by
orders. Committees to find means of conciliation are appointed by each
chamber; but conciliation is impossible. Some think the Nobles could
be induced to unite themselves with the
higher Clergy into one House, the lower Clergy and Tiers Etat
forming another. But the Tiers Etat are immovable. They are not only
firm, but a little disdainful. The question is, what will ensue? One
idea is to separate, in order to consult again their constituents, and
to take new instructions. This would be doing nothing, for the same
instructions would be repeated; and what, in the meantime, is to
become of a government, absolutely without money, and which cannot be
kept in motion with less than a million of livres a day? The more
probable expectation is as follows. As soon as it shall become evident
that no amicable determination of the manner of voting can take place,
the Tiers Etat will send an invitation to the two other orders to come
and take their places in the common chamber. A majority of the Clergy
will go, and the minority of the Noblesse. The chamber thus composed
will declare that the States General are constituted, will notify it
to the King, and that they are ready to proceed to business. If the
King refuses to do business with them, and adheres to the Nobles, the
common chamber will declare all taxes at an end, will form a
declaration of rights, and do such other acts as circum stances will
permit, and go home. The tax-gatherers will then be resisted, and it
may well be doubted whether the soldiery and their officers will not
divide, as the Tiers Etat and Nobles. But it is more likely that the
King will agree to do business with the States General.
to Thomas Paine, 19 May 1789
|