The Correspondence of Thomas Jefferson
By Subject
PAINE, THOMAS / OPINION OF
You ask my opinion of Lord Bolingbroke and Thomas Paine. They were
alike in making bitter enemies of the priests and pharisees of their
day. Both were honest men; both advocates for human liberty. Paine
wrote for a country which permitted him to push his reasoning to
whatever length it would go. Lord Bolingbroke in one restrained by a
constitution, and by public opinion. He was called indeed a tory; but
his writings prove him a stronger advocate for liberty than any of his
countrymen, the Whigs of the present day. Irritated by his exile, he
committed one act unworthy of him, in connecting himself momentarily
with a prince rejected by his country. But he redeemed that single act
by his establishment of the principles which proved it to be wrong.
These two persons differed remarkably in the style of their writing,
each leaving a model of what is most perfect in both extremes of the
simple and the sublime. No writer has exceeded Paine in ease and
familiarity of style, in perspicuity of expression, happiness of
elucidation, and in simple and unassuming language. In this he may be
compared with Doctor Franklin; and indeed his
Common Sense was, for a while, believed to have been written
by Doctor Franklin, and published under the borrowed name of Paine,
who had come over with him from England. Lord Bolingbroke's, on the
other hand, is a style of the highest order. The lofty, rhythmical,
full-flowing eloquence of Cicero. Periods of just measure, their
members proportioned, their close full and round. His conceptions,
too, are bold and strong, his diction copious, polished and commanding
as his subject. His writings are certainly the finest samples in the
English language, of the eloquence proper for the Senate. His
political tracts are safe reading for the most timid religionist, his
philosophical, for those who are not afraid to trust their reason with
discussions of right and wrong.
You have asked my opinion of these persons, and, to you, I
have given it freely. But, remember, that I am old, that I wish not to
make new enemies, nor to give offense to those who would consider a
difference of opinion as sufficient ground for unfriendly
dispositions.
to Francis Eppes, 19 January 1821
|