Benjamin Franklin's Role
in the Writing of Common Sense
Edward J. Dodson
[Reprinted from the
Bulletin of Thomas Paine Friends,
Vol. 10, No.4, Winter
Among the many details of Paine's accomplishments subject to ongoing
discussion is the relationship he enjoyed with Benjamin Franklin.
Clearly, Franklin was both friend to and mentor of Paine. With good
reason, Paine could not but have enormous respect for this older man
of letters and science.
How the pamphlet Common Sense came to be written by Paine is a matter
of historical record. One of the most detailed and interesting
presentations of this episode is provided by Edward Larkin in his
introduction to a 2004 reprinting of Common Sense.
Interestingly, Larkin does not comment one way or the other on
Various biographers of both Paine and Franklin assert that Franklin
did, in fact, review the manuscript. Thomas Slaughter, in the
introduction to Common Sense and Related Writings of Thomas Paine,
states: "Benjamin Franklin and Samuel Adams also helped Paine
with his text." And, Walter Isaacson, in his biography of
Franklin, writes: "Franklin offered his wholehearted support
along with a few suggested revisions." The facts may have been
different, as detailed in Alfred Aldridge's 1984 book, Thomas
Paine's American Ideology. The only assertion of Franklin's
involvement was made by William Duane, who in 1818 published
Franklin's memoirs. As Aldridge tells us, a month after the pamphlet
appeared, Franklin privately wrote to General Charles Lee that did not
know who had authored Common Sense. However, Paine later wrote
that he sent to Franklin the very first copy that came off the
printing press. Would it not be strange that this copy found its way
to Franklin without an accompanying note from Paine?
What we are left with is the account of events left by Dr. Benjamin
Rush in a letter he wrote to James Cheetham in 1809. In reading this
account, it is worth recalling, as Aldridge observes, that Rush "came
to dislike Paine for his religious ideas and consequently made no
attempt to be complimentary in his reminiscences."
"About the year 1775, I read a short essay with
which I was much pleased, in one of Bradford's [news]papers, against
the slavery of the Africans in our country, and which, I was
informed, was written by Thomas Paine. This excited my curiosity to
be better acquainted with him. We met soon afterwards at Mr.
Aitkins' bookstore, where I did homage to his principles and his pen
on the subject of the enslaved Africans. He told me that it was the
first piece he had ever published here.
When the subject of American Independence began to be agitated in
conversation, I observed the publick mind to be loaded with an
immense mass of prejudice and error relative to it. Something
appeared to be wanting, to remove them beyond the ordinary short and
cold addresses of newspaper publications. At this time I called upon
Mr. Paine, and suggested to him the propriety of preparing our
citizens for a perpetual separation of our country from Great
Britain, by means of a work of such length as would obviate all the
objections to it. He seized the idea with avidity, and immediately
began his famous pamphlet in favour of that measure.
He read the sheets to me at my house as he composed them. When he
had finished them, I advised him to put them into the hands of Dr.
Benjamin Franklin, Samuel Adams, and the late Judge James Wilson,
assuring him, at the same time, that they all held the same opinions
that he had defended. The first of those gentlemen saw the
manuscript, and I believe the second, but Judge Wilson being from
home when Mr. Paine called upon him, it was not subjected to his
inspection. No addition was made to it by Dr. Franklin, but a
passage was struck out, or omitted in printing it, which I conceived
to be the most striking in it. It was the following-"A greater
absurdity cannot be conceived of, than three millions of people
running to their sea coast every time a ship arrives from London, to
know what portion of liberty they should enjoy."
A title only was wanted for this pamphlet before it was committed
to the press. Mr. Paine proposed to call it "Plain Truth."
I objected to it and suggested the title of "Common Sense."
This was instantly adopted, and nothing now remained, but to find a
printer who had boldness enough to publish it. ..."
However it all came together, what is certain is that Paine captured
in words the sentiments of those who clearly thought of themselves as
Americans - even if they could not yet openly to say so.